Socrates

Renderings of the Daimonion Across Editions

The Greek term το δαιμόνιον (to daimonion) is a neuter adjective used as a noun—literally “the daimonic thing.”  Translators have rendered it in strikingly different ways.

Direct Translations of the Term

  • The divine thing
  • The divine sign
  • The divine and daimonic thing — Thomas G. West (1984)
  • Something divine and spiritual — Harold North Fowler, Loeb (1914)
  • Something divine and miraculous — David Horan, Platonic Foundation translation
  • A personal guardian spirit — Chris Emlyn-Jones (scholarly gloss, 1990)

Jowett’s Six Renderings (1871)

  • An oracle
  • A sign
  • The divinity
  • A voice
  • The divine faculty
  • The internal oracle

Transliteration & Foreign-Language Titles

  • The daimonion — bare transliteration, common in modern scholarship
  • Genius — Latin tradition, from Plutarch’s De genio Socratis
  • The god of Socrates — Apuleius, De deo Socratis
  • Dämon — German scholarship
  • Daimôn-ish / weird — the archaic English sense of “uncanny, fated,” suggested by one Notre Dame reviewer

Glosses on Its Operation

  • A sort of voice (phonē tis)
  • A sign (sēmeion)
  • A signal
  • An inward monitor

Sources: Jowett (Lexundria; MIT Internet Classics Archive); Fowler (Perseus Digital Library); West, Plato’s Apology of Socrates (1984); Horan (platonicfoundation.org); reviews of Socrates’ Divine Sign: Religion, Practice, and Value in Socratic Philosophy (Apeiron 38.2, 2005) at Bryn Mawr Classical Review and Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews; Emlyn-Jones, “Socrates, Plato, and Piety” (Greece & Rome, 1990).